Throughout its history, Actors' has been recognized for its work, including awards from the American Association of Community Theatres, Between the Lines newspaper, On The Town - Townie Awards and over 70 Grand Awards for excellence in Grand Rapids theatre.
On The Town Silver Townie Award for Best Live Theatre Company in 2007
Actors' Theatre's production of Top Girls received the Outstanding State of Michigan Production, Outstanding Regional Production, and Second Runner Up for Outstanding National Production by American Association of Community Theatres in 1992
Actors' Theatre's production of Corpus Christi received a Special Award from Between the Lines newspaper at their Wilde Awards in Detroit, 2003
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play — Dylan Harris, Love! Valour! Compassion
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play - Jeffrey Williams, Love! Valour! Compassion
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play — Kyle Los, Venus In Fur
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play — Ellie Frances, Venus In Fur
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical — Kathy Gibson, Grey Gardens
Outstanding Scenic Design — Christian Poquette, Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson
Outstanding Direction of a Play — Michelle Urbane, Venus In Fur
Outstanding Production of a Play — Venus In Fur
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play — Andrew McClelland, Looking For Normal
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play — Kitty Carrico Carpenter, Looking For Normal
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical —Maggie Nye, Next To Normal
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play — Todd Lewis, A Steady Rain
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play — Rena Dam, Nadia
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical — Kelly Carey, Next To Normal
Outstanding Scenic Design — Christian Poquette, Next To Normal
Outstanding Direction of a Play — Jeralyn Pinsky, A Steady Rain
Outstanding Direction of a Musical — Fred Sebulske,Next To Normal
Outstanding Production of a Play — A Steady Rain
Outstanding Production of a Musical — Next To Normal
Outstanding Choreography — Kyle Amanda Dutkiewicz, Spring Awakening
Outstanding Lighting Design — Paul Dreher, August:Osage County
Outstanding Scenic Design — Christian Poquette, August:Osage County
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play — Jean Reed Bahle, August:Osage County
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical — Maggie Nye, Spring Awakening
Outstanding Direction of a Play — Fred Sebulske, August:Osage County
Outstanding Direction of a Musical — Fred Sebulske,Spring Awakening
Outstanding Production of a Play — August:Osage County
Outstanding Production of a Musical — Spring Awakening
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play: Steven Anderson, Opus
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play: Jolene Frankey, The Sweetest Swing in Baseball
Outstanding Director of a Play: Fred Sebulske, Distracted
Outstanding Choreography: Mary Lohman, Reefer Madness
Outstanding Production of a Play: Top Dog/Underdog
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play: Kristina Scripsema - Mr. Marmalade
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play: Ralph Lister - Frozen
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play: Rebecca Monterusso - Frozen
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play: Dylan Harris - Mr. Marmalade
Outstanding Direction of a Play: Fred Sebulske - Top Dog/Underdog
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical:Carrie McNulty – The Wild Party
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical: Lynne Brown Tepper – The Wild Party
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical: Stephen Grey – The Wild Party
Outstanding Director of a Musical : Kyle Amanda Dutkiewicz and Craig Hammerlind – The Wild Party
Outstanding Set Design: Christian Poquette, Seven Passages: The Stories of Gay Christians
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play: Julianne Howe - Going To St. Ives
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play: Dylan Harris - Rabbit Hole
Outstanding Musical: Kiss of the Spider Woman
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical: Carrie A. McNulty – Kiss of the Spider Woman
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical: Larry Young – Kiss of the Spider Woman
Outstanding Director of a Musical: Fred Sebulske – Kiss of the Spider Woman
Outstanding Director of a Musical - Fred Sebulske, Side Show
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play - Tim Moriarty, Fat Pig
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical - Chris Flowers, Side Show
Outstanding Set Design - Rosanne Steffens, Intimate Apparel
Outstanding Costume Design - Bob Fowle, Side Show
Outstanding Lighting Design - Paul Dreher, Intimate Apparel
Outstanding Musical - Urinetown, The Musical
Outstanding Play - Jesus Hopped the "A" Train
Outstanding Director of a Musical - Fred Sebulske, Urinetown:The Musical
Outstanding Director of a Play - Fred Sebulske, Jesus Hopped the "A" Train
Outstanding Actress in a Play - Jean Reed Bahle, Elizabeth Rex
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play - Amy Osborn Kaechele, Kimberly Akimbo
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical - Larry Young, Urinetown, The Musical
Outstanding Supporting actress in a Musical - Liz Dykhouse, Assassins
Outstanding Choreography - Kyle Amanda Dutkiewicz, Urinetown, The Musical
Outstanding Musical Direction - Michael Shansky, Urinetown, The Musical
Outstanding Set Design - Christian Poquette, Urinetown, The Musical
Outstanding Lighting Design - Jennifer Kules, Urinetown, The Musical
Outstanding Costume Design - Marcia Van Kuiken, Elizabeth Rex
Outstanding Play - The Exonerated
Outstanding Director of a Play - Jeralyn Pinsky, The Exonerated
Outstanding Actress in a Play - Jean Reed Bahle, The Goat, or Who is Sylvia?
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play - Joe Lachappelle, The Exonerated
Outstanding Lighting Design - Catherine Dreher, The Rocky Horror Picture Show
Outstanding Choreography - Kyle Amanda Dutkiewicz, The Rocky Horror Picture Show
Outstanding Musical - The Spitfire Grill
Outstanding Director of Musical - Jean Reed Bahle, The Spitfire Grill
Outstanding Actress in a musical - Mandy Hutchins, The Spitfire Grill
Outstanding Actress in a Play - Lisa Nowak, Boy Gets Girl
Outstanding Musical Direction - Margi Derks Peterson & Kathy Wagner, The Spitfire Grill
Outstanding Play - Corpus Christi
Outstanding Musical - Bat Boy, The Musical
Outstanding Director of a Play - Fred Sebulske, Corpus Christi
Outstanding Director of a Musical - Fred Sebulske, Bat Boy, The Musical
Outstanding Lead Actor in Musical - Jason Townes, Bat Boy, The Musical
Outstanding Lead Actress in Musical - Kelly Carey, Bat Boy, The Musical
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Musical - Larry Young, Bat Boy, The Musical
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical- Laurie Veldheer, Bat Boy, The Musical
Outstanding Musical Director - Michael Shansky & Duane Davis - Pacific Overtures
Outstanding Lighting Design - Jen Kules, Bat Boy, The Musical
Outstanding Director of a Play - Fred Sebulske, Quills
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play - John Rich, Quills
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Play - Christy Beatty, The Waverly Gallery
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play - Rachel Carter, The Waverly Gallery
Outstanding Actress in a Musical - Lynne Brown, Violet
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play - Greg Rogers, The Cripple of Innishmaan
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play - Marney Macadam, The Cripple of Innishmaan
Outstanding Musical - Floyd Collins
Outstanding Director of a Musical - Fred Sebulske, Floyd Collins
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical - Dan Gillisse, Floyd Collins
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical - Kelly Ronan, Floyd Collins
Outstanding Musical Director - Michael Shansky, Floyd Collins
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play - Joe Miller, Our Country's Good
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play - Jean Reed Bahle, Our Country's Good
Outstanding Play - Oleanna
Outstanding Director of a Play - Fred Sebulske, The Perfect Ganesh
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Play - Fred Stella, The Perfect Ganesh
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play - Curt Buckley, The Perfect Ganesh